Comparative Study of the Image of Peter the Great as Presented in Educational Literature in the PRC, UK and USA.
https://doi.org/10.25205/1818-7919-2022-21-4-81-91
Abstract
This article is the first comparative analysis of world history schoolbooks recommended for secondary educational establishments in the PRC, UK and USA. The aim is to determine and contrast the ways these didactic materials represent one of the most recognizable and impressive cultural symbols of Russia – Emperor Peter the Great. The choice of the sources for the analysis is explained by the fact that due to secondary education being compulsory in all three countries, the ‘school’ information about world history, including Russia, becomes available to wide masses of society, therefore influencing the image of Peter I formed by the population. Several aspects are taken into consideration – the amount of information offered in the books, the factual material itself, and the way the Russia of Peter the Great is described. Contrasting these makes it possible to reveal similarities and differences. The authors discover that the period of Peter the Great’s reign is included, if rather briefly, in the curricula of Chinese and American high schools, while no mentioning of it is found in history schoolbooks of the UK. Compilers of these books, both in China and the USA, seemingly strive to adhere to the principle of historical accuracy. As for some differences, the textbooks of the PRC acquaint readers with the historical material in a more uniformed way, offering a conceptually consistent ‘standard’ set of facts about Peter the Great, which, to some extent, corresponds to the current situation in the PRC, while the history schoolbooks of the USA are less standardized and motivate students to think critically.
About the Authors
N. А. Samoylov
St. Petersburg State University
Russian Federation
Nikolay A. Samoylov, Doctor of Sciences (History), Professor
Russian Federation
Nikolay A. Samoylov, Doctor of Sciences (History), Professor
St. Petersburg
E. G. Andreeva
St. Petersburg State University
Russian Federation
Ekaterina G. Andreeva, Candidate of Science (Philology), Associate ProfessorSt. Petersburg
Russian Federation
Ekaterina G. Andreeva, Candidate of Science (Philology), Associate ProfessorSt. Petersburg
References
1. Everything You Need to Ace World History in One Big Fat Notebook: The Complete Middle School Study Guide. Ed. by Michael Lindblad, New York, Workman Publishing, 2016, 502 p.
2. Gombrich E. H. A Little History of the World, New Haven, London, Yale Uni. Press, 2005, 305 p. Lankova E. V. Evaluation for Peter the Great’s reform activities in the articles of Chinese historians of the 1980s and the 1990s. Proceedings of Petrozavodsk State University, 2020, vol. 42, no. 8, pp. 23–29. (in Russ.) DOI 10.15393/uchz.art.2020.546
3. Lankova E. V. Rets. na kn.: U He. Reformy Petra Velikogo [Review of the book: Wu He. Reforms of Peter the Great]. Proceedings of Petrozavodsk State University, 2021, vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 122–125. (in Russ.) DOI 10.15393/uchz.art.2021.665
4. Lishi: Putong gaozhong kecheng biaozhun shiyan jiaokeshu. Cao Dawei, Guo Xiaoling zhubian [历史：普通高中课程标准实验教科书。曹大为、郭小凌主编]. History: The Standard Experimental Textbook for the General High School Education. Ed. by Cao Dawei, Guo Xiaoling. Changsha, Yuelu shushe publishers, 2011, 141 p. (in Chin.)
5. Maiatskii D. I. Foreign policy of Peter the Great in the articles of Chinese historians of the 1980s and the 1990s. Proceedings of Petrozavodsk State University, 2020, vol. 42, no. 6, pp. 15–23. (in Russ.) DOI 10.15393/uchz.art.2020.512
6. Samoylov N. A. Obraz Petra Pervogo v “Zapiskah” cinskogo poslannika Tulishenya [Image of Peter I in the “Records” written by the Qing Dynasty Diplomat Tulišen]. Klio, 2021, no. 5 (173), pp. 33–42. (in Russ.) DOI 10.51676/2070-9773_2021_05_33
7. Samoylov N. A. Peter the Great’s contribution to the socio-cultural interaction of Russia with East Asian countries. Proceedings of Petrozavodsk State University, 2021, vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 65–76. (in Russ.) DOI 10.15393/uchz.art.2021.658
8. Samoylov N. A., Mayatskii D. I. Petr Velikij v kitajskoj publicistike XIX – nachala XX v. [Peter the Great in Chinese Journals of the 19th and early 20th Century]. In: Problemy literatur Dal'nego Vostoka. Izbrannye materialy IX mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferencii [Issues of the Far Eastern Literatures. Selected Materials of the IX International Scientific Conference]. St. Petersburg, SPbSU, 2021, pp. 454–465. (in Russ.)
9. Shijie lishi: Yiwu jiaoyu jiaokeshu. Jiu nianji shang ce. Kecheng jiaocai yanjiusuo lishi kecheng jiaocai yanjiu kaifa zhongxin bianzhu [世界历史：义务教育教科书。九年级上册。课程教材研究所历史课程教材研究开发中心编著]. World History: A Textbook for Compulsory Education. Grade 9, part 1. Compiled by the Research Center for Educational Materials on the History of the Research Institute for Educational Literature. Beijing, Renmin jiaoyu chubanshe, 2009, 159 p. (in Chin.)
10. Shijie lishi: Yiwu jiaoyu jiaokeshu. Jiu nianji xia ce. Gong Jizhu zhubian [世界历史：义务教育教科书。九年级下册。龚奇柱主编]. World History: A Textbook for Compulsory Education. Grade 9, part 2. Ed. by Gong Jizhu. Chengdu, Sichuan jiaoyu publishers, 2018, 140 p. (in Chin.)
11. The Oxford Illustrated History of the World, ed. by Felipe Fernandez-Armesto. Oxford, Oxford Uni. Press, 2019, 496 p.
12. World History: Patterns of Interaction, Student Edition Survey. Secondary (senior high) school. Comp. by Roger B. Beck etc. Boston, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2010, 1320 p.
Review
For citations:
Samoylov N.А., Andreeva E.G. Comparative Study of the Image of Peter the Great as Presented in Educational Literature in the PRC, UK and USA. Vestnik NSU. Series: History and Philology. 2022;21(4):81-91. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.25205/1818-7919-2022-21-4-81-91
Views:
305
Email this article 